DOUBLE TAKE NOSE NEWS

The scent of a man

Taking the Pill can make a woman sniff out a partner who’s genetically inappropriate, says British research

The Globe and Mail,  Thursday Aug. 14, 2008

 

BY PHILIP JACKMAN

A woman taking the Pill is more likely to choose a I\man who is genetically wrong for her because of her altered perception of his odour, according to new research.

A British study says women are naturally attracted through their sense of smell to men who are genetically dissimilar to them. It's a way to diversify the gene pool and produce children who; for example, have stronger immune systems.

It's due to a group of about 140 genes in an area called the major histocompatibility complex that plays a key role in odour through interaction with skin bacteria.

But the hormones in the Pill can alter a woman's ability to sniff out a suitable mate and make her feel more attracted to men who are genetically similar. Oversimilar gene profiles can result in difficulty trying to conceive, an increased risk of miscarriage and a weaker immune system, earlier research has shown.

Furthermore, the new study says, if the woman stops taking the Pill, it could lead to "partnership breakdown" when she realizes she has chosen Mr. Wrong.

Craig Roberts, a lecturer in biological sciences at the University of Liverpool and the lead author of the study, said in a telephone interview yester-day that the research arose from a study in the mid-1990s "that was aimed at seeing whether humans could do the same thing as, for example, mice. Could females pick out the smell of genetically similar or dissimilar males?"

The research suggested that humans could, but the findings were inconclusive because, among other things, the sample of only 18 Pill users was statistically too small.

So a team led by Dr. Roberts, who was at the University of Newcastle when the study was conducted, asked a group of about 100 women to indicate which of six male body-odour samples they found most attractive, both before and after going on the Pill.

The male scents were drawn from 97 volunteers who were told to avoid using deodorants and were provided with non-perfumed soap. They also had to be non-smokers.

"We found that the preferences of women having gone on the Pill shifted toward genetic similarity," Dr. Roberts said. "It suggests that it is specifically the hormonal levels within the Pill" that produce this effect.

Oral contraceptives combine two hormones, estrogen and progestogen, to inhibit normal female fertility.

But what effect can all this have on a couple's relation-ship?

It does carry potential implications "both in terms of successful pregnancies - carrying babies to term - and potential-ly in terms of your relationship quality," Dr. Roberts said.

He also pointed to a U.S. study of 60 couples in which "the women who were relatively similar to their partner [genetically] reported lower relationship satisfaction and a greater likelihood of going off to seek affairs."

So would it be a good idea for a woman who's planning to walk down the aisle to stop taking the Pill for a while be-fore the nuptials?

"While I wouldn't presume to tell women what to do," Dr. Roberts said, "a period of assessment using non-hormonal contraceptives" might be worth considering.

The study, co-authored by L. Morris Gosling, Vaughan Carter and Marion Petrie, was pub-lished in the science journal Proceedings of the Royal Society.

 

)) With a report from Agence France-Presse